DeleteMe alternatives, matched to why you’re switching
By Jean Luc Poitier, SEO and growth marketing strategist · Optery Reviews · Updated November 1, 2026 · Grounded in 100 recent DeleteMe reviews
Disclosure: this site reviews Optery and earns a commission if you sign up for it through our links. Optery is one option below, and we say where it isn't the right fix.
Why people look past DeleteMe
DeleteMe’s Trustpilot score is 3.6 across 264 reviews. Of its 100 most recent (March 2025 to September 2026), 70 were invited and averaged 4.3. The 30 written unprompted averaged 1.9, and they give three reasons for leaving.
Paying, then waiting for a first report. Several reviewers paid for a year and saw no report, or no removals, for weeks.
“My dashboard shows 553 exposures reviewed and 0 removals worked on.”Momeees, Trustpilot, September 2026
“Joined a month ago, still no report.”Molly Pfau Clopp, Trustpilot, July 2026
Sites marked clean that weren’t. Some reviewers checked the report against the sites themselves.
“I manually checked each site and 95% of them had my info on them.”J S, Trustpilot, April 2026
Custom requests that move slowly. Reviewers who asked for sites outside the standard list describe months in a queue.
“They are very slow at responding to custom requests.”DM, Trustpilot, June 2026
A caution that applies to every service here: none of them controls who calls you, and Optery’s own critical reviews include the complaint that spam didn’t drop. Choose on what you can verify.
Match the DeleteMe alternative to your reason for leaving
| Compared on | Best alternative | Check before switching |
|---|---|---|
| You paid and waited weeks for a report | Optery: a free exposure report with screenshots before you pay | Removals themselves still take weeks to months |
| Your report said clean and you weren't | Optery Extended: before-and-after screenshots every ~90 days | $14.99/mo or $149/yr; a few reviewers still dispute results |
| You don't want a 1- or 2-year term | Optery: monthly billing from $3.99, pause or cancel any time | Plans auto-renew by default |
| Custom requests stalled | Optery Ultimate: unlimited custom removals, 940+ sites | Top tier at $24.99/mo; eligible after 30 days |
| You want the lowest annual price | Incogni Standard: $95.88/yr for 420+ brokers | Unprompted reviews average 2.7 |
| You want identity theft cover too | Aura: removal plus credit monitoring and insurance | Its Trustpilot sample is 86% invited |
Figures checked against each company's published pages and review-platform listings as of November 2026. “Not published” means the company does not publish that figure.
The 4 best DeleteMe alternatives
Optery
A free scan first, screenshots afterOn unprompted Trustpilot reviews, Optery averages 4.0 across its 50 most recent and DeleteMe averages 1.9 across 30 (October 2026 pulls). The free plan shows your listings with screenshots before you pay, which answers the most common DeleteMe complaint: paying and then waiting weeks for a first report. Paid plans run $3.99 to $24.99 a month, billed monthly or yearly, and Extended adds before-and-after screenshots every ~90 days. Weak spots from its own reviews: the big brokers can take months, some reviewers saw no drop in spam calls, and support is email only.
Full Optery vs DeleteMe comparison →Incogni
Low annual price, simple setupIncogni Standard is $95.88 a year ($7.99/mo billed annually) for 420+ brokers, with a 30-day money-back guarantee; Unlimited ($179.88/yr) adds custom removals and live phone support (Incogni's pricing page, September 2026). Its unprompted Trustpilot reviews average 2.7 (26 of the 100 most recent), ahead of DeleteMe's 1.9 but behind Optery's 4.0. Caveat: reviewers report an annual charge they took for monthly and removals they couldn't see.
Optery vs Incogni →Aura
Removal inside a full identity-theft suiteAura adds data broker removal to credit monitoring, identity theft insurance, and device security. Individual plans are $12/mo billed annually or $15 month to month, with a 14-day free trial and a 60-day money-back guarantee on annual plans (Aura's pricing page, September 2026). Caveat: 43 of its 50 most recent Trustpilot reviews were invited, so its high score there tells you little.
Optery vs Aura →Do it yourself
Free, and you check every site yourselfSeveral DeleteMe reviewers ended up checking sites by hand anyway. The manual route costs nothing but time: 10 to 30 minutes a site, then quarterly re-checks because brokers relist people.
The manual opt-out guide →
When to stay with DeleteMe
Stay if your reports arrive and your listings are going down. DeleteMe assigns a named privacy expert on every plan and covers unlimited aliases and past names, which matters if you’ve changed names. Families on a 4-person plan may also find switching everyone at once more trouble than it’s worth.
If you’re leaving because you can’t see what DeleteMe did, start with Optery’s free scan. It shows which sites still list you, with screenshots, so you know what your current service missed before you cancel. Read every Optery review we collected, the critical ones included.
Run a free Optery scanHow we sourced this: on October 1, 2026 we pulled the 100 most recent DeleteMe reviews on Trustpilot (March 20, 2025 to September 9, 2026) and the 50 most recent Optery reviews; some quotes come from an earlier pull on September 27. Trustpilot labels each review as invited by the company or written unprompted (“organic”); we averaged the two groups separately. Quotes are verbatim. Prices come from each company’s own pricing page, checked September 29, 2026.
DeleteMe alternatives FAQ
What are the best DeleteMe alternatives?+
Optery if you want to see your exposure for free before paying and get screenshot proof afterwards; its unprompted Trustpilot reviews average 4.0 to DeleteMe's 1.9. Incogni for a low annual price. Aura if you also want credit monitoring and identity theft insurance. The manual route if you have the time.
What do DeleteMe reviews say?+
Of the 100 most recent DeleteMe reviews on Trustpilot (March 2025 to September 2026), 70 were invited and averaged 4.3; the 30 unprompted reviews averaged 1.9. The unprompted complaints repeat: first reports that took weeks or never arrived, sites marked clean that still listed the reviewer, and slow custom requests.
Is Optery better than DeleteMe?+
On unprompted reviews, clearly: 4.0 for Optery's 50 most recent against 1.9 for DeleteMe's 30. Optery also has a free tier and monthly billing, where DeleteMe sells 1- and 2-year terms. DeleteMe's advantage is a named privacy expert on every plan; Optery assigns a human Privacy Agent from Extended up.
Does DeleteMe publish its pricing?+
Yes. For US residents, 1-year plans are $129 for one person, $229 for two, and $329 for four; 2-year plans are $209, $349, and $499. All renew automatically, and there is no monthly option (DeleteMe's pricing page, September 2026).